Mafia: The Rellyw Rebellion - Game Thread

Aryanne

OoooooOOOOoooooo ya'll need to hurry up so I can find out who the other bad guys were OOOooOoooooooOOoo

Macavity

we are waiting on @Omei for the closing of the day and moving on to the night

Omei

Alright.

Ilyon (7): Teani, Vharen, Macavity, Xenia, Haern, Esper, Demarcus
Teani (1): Ilyon

After a long day of deliberation in the ruins and slaughter of the Basilica, you finally decide, by common consensus of 'I feel like it', to stab Ilyon messily to death.

So you do this.

...oops.

Ilyon has been killed. He was a Rellyw.

It is now Round Sixteen - Night.

Aarbrok

OoooOoOOOooo GOTCHA! OoooOoOOOOoooO!!

Teani

Well, damn. That was annoying. Sorry, Ilyon.

Would have been good with some information, but as it is there's no sharing, once more leaving us in the dark and it's giving the Conclaves the upper hand.

Haern

Oops. We dun goofed.

Demarcus

Dangit. I guess Periluna didn't have that good of information. Bleh.

Teani

Ilyon was on the 'not-confirmed' list, but that wouldn't necessarily make him scum. I went some on gut too, but it seems that failed me this time. Been good at guessing before though.

Periluna

OoooOOoOooOOHeeey! Moirean goofed with Kaeus too! OoooOoooOoOOOoOOOOooooo!!!!!

Vharen

Aarbrok made a good play and pointed a finger at someone in a list that showed who was suspicious to us. With 6 people on it, and Aarb knowing three of them, he had a 66% chance of naming a Rellyw, and he didn't care either way. 

That does not mean her information was unsound.

QuoteThing

Toz, Aldric, Ilyon, Aryanne, Aarbrok, Piper, Jasline, Xenia, Demarcus, Esper.

Endquote

That was her list. Toz, Aryanne, Aarbrok, Jasline, all guilty. We've snagged four people from the list and only the fifth has proven wrong so far. Now we have...

Aldric, Piper, Xenia, Demarcus, Esper

Five people left, three are bad. I wonder why you were quick to discredit something that has proven itself fairly on point so far, Demarcus.

Toz

OooOoOo I only read this thread to see Vharen's sig now OOoooOOoo

Vharen

No soup for OooOOooo

Periluna

OoooOOoo ghost don't eat soup OoooOOoo

Omei

You're awoken by what is now becoming a regular occurrence...

...the Ankyreans dropping someone from the balcony.

The corpse, after some effort on your parts, is deduced to be Vharen.

He was the Syssin.

It is now Round Seventeen - Day. Let's all try to do our best today!

You require five votes for a successful lynch.

Macavity

Now that the Syssin is gone lets start this off on the right foot.  I have long since believed that Demarcus was bad and now its time to cut him out of this game for good.  He said it himself in the last day round that he has disagreed and fought against me this whole game.  Its time to start killing off the rest of the bad people so us Rellyw can live free!!

VOTE: Demarcus

Demarcus

Macavity said:

Now that the Syssin is gone lets start this off on the right foot.  I have long since believed that Demarcus was bad and now its time to cut him out of this game for good.  He said it himself in the last day round that he has disagreed and fought against me this whole game.  Its time to start killing off the rest of the bad people so us Rellyw can live free!!

VOTE: Demarcus

So that automatically makes me bad? Fortunately, I'm not going to retaliate by saying that Macavity is a bad guy, because I have strong suspicions that he's a good guy. Macavity was wrong blatantly wrong about Moirean, dare I say he's been pretty awful about guessing. My track record, however? Pretty damn impeccable. On both Indorani AND Conclaves. At this stage of the game, I'm going to go with us needing people who can actually identify baddies versus... Macavity. Last round it was Xenia, now it's me. I think he just wants to put a feather in his hat, or something.

Personally, I'd be more inclined to lean towards Aldric and Piper. If they're not playing anymore, and we haven't seen much activity out of the Conclaves (albeit this is limited without the Warden's posts... nudge nudge, Warden!) I'm thinking one or both of them are Conclave, although probably different Conclave. So...

Vote: Aldric

Xenia

I tend to agree with @Demarcus on his reasoning. Last day round @Macavity was set on me, and while there's not any substantial evidence in my innocence, he's been aggressive against, to me, what seems like the wrong people. 

I am personally more inclined to vote Piper than Aldric because I think if Aldric had a power role, he'd still be checking in and playing. 

Vote: Piper

Meskhenet

To add to what @Xenia said, that makes sense to me. Piper did the same thing last game, and was a power role.

Vote: Piper

Teani

Piper has been on my list of suspects for a long time. I'd rather go with her than Aldric at this point, Demarcus, so if you care to switch maybe?

Vote Piper

Macavity

I actually think that Piper, Aldric and Demarcus are the last three conclaves left and to at least kill one of them..

UNVOTE: Demarcus

VOTE: Piper

Demarcus

Teani said:

Piper has been on my list of suspects for a long time. I'd rather go with her than Aldric at this point, Demarcus, so if you care to switch maybe?

Vote Piper

No sweat off my back. I was going by alphabetical order.

Unvote: Aldric

Vote: Piper

Teani

I'm wondering why we're not getting any ANON reports at least from the Warden. There's no noise at all. I mean, yes, this game has gone on for a LOONG time, but there are few people left. Would be kind of nice if we could end this in a good fashion, with those who are in it actually participating and making an effort these last few round.

Omei

As the number of citizens left in the city dwindles, you unanimously agree that the only solution is to kill yet more of them.

When you haul Piper forward, kicking and screaming - a noted contrast to her utter silence up until this point - you are all too familiar with trussing up victims and hauling them up the Basilica pillars. She kicks, struggles, and tries to escape, but as the sunlight strikes her she begins to burn, and scream, and claw at the rope.

Unfortunately, this is the Second Mortal Epoch.

They haven't got vampires quite right yet.

Piper has fried like a bug in the sunlight. She was the Consanguine Experiment.

No faction possesses a night kill.

It is now Round Eighteen - Night.

Teani

Yay!

So now we have Magic (who blocks powers) and Nature (who sends people out on scouting missions) left.

We haven't seen anyone who has been sent out on scouting missions in a good while. I believe the last time they used their powers were when that whole massacre went down on page 25. All Conclaves focused on Toz. He was blocked by Magic and Nature attempted to save from day lynch, but Rebels got to him before dawn.

Confirmed Loyalists so far are Toz and Aryanne.
Confirmed Rebels so far are Aarbrok and Piper.

We have had no reports since Periluna's death, but thanks to this recent kill, we have the upper hand again.

Looking back a bit I notice that Xenia claimed Aryanne flew under her radar, asking me to clarify why she was on my suspect list. Could mean that she's in their conclave, trying to get me to fumble my reasons in some way to wave it off. Don't know. She was also on my list of suspects back then. Just some thoughts as we wait to hear what happens during this night. At least we get to sleep without fear of death!

Demarcus

Woot woot! I'm still pretty convinced that Aldric is one of the remaining Conclaves, and Esper is my choice for the second and final Conclave member, but I'll need to review my notes to verify.

Macavity

I am going to throw this out and say and confirm what Aarbrok stated just before he died.

I AM the Jailer!  **bows**

I am the one that has been locking others up and what not and working behind the scenes with the other power roles of the Rellwy.  Now based on all the information we have gathered and spoke about on our side conversation, this is what we have come up with...

Demarcus is the last Rebel, Aldric is the Loyalist

So when the day round starts I will start a vote for Demarcus to kill him off then Aldric.

Also the reason why you have not seen reports from the Warden, who will remain nameless, is because there have not been any to post.  Most of the power roles that would show up on that report died in the massive killings we had, and thus far no reason to post anything.

Demarcus

So let me get this straight. You claim Moirean is in a Conclave. You refuse to work with the one confirmed Rellyw. But once they're gone, you can suddenly work with the Rellyw again? And now based on this one proclaimation/roleclaim you suddenly hold the keys to everything? I'll remain a little skeptical, and not just because you're again going to try and kill me.. I'll get onboard with killing Aldric and the other Conclave member, but I'm not going to waste my time or yours lynching myself.

Essentially, you're telling me that I'm going to out Piper, debunk Aarbrok's crummy defenses, and kill both of them -- getting rid of Piper, mind you, costs me a night kill tonight, and be on their team? I don't know about that logic. I kill Indorani, I kill Rebels, all the Loyalists so far killed were killed by the hands of mysterious night-folk, and yet I'm a Rebel. Right. Just like Moirean and I are in the same Conclave. I'll give you that Moieran and I are/were on the same side, just not in a Conclave.

I had Macavity pegged as a good guy. Now I can't say I'm entirely so sure. The Loyalists sent Toz out on a scouting expedition at least once. Macavity also went out scouting. He could be telling the truth about being the Jailer, but he very well might be the Dhasan of Nature.

Xenia

@Demarcus, I too have found @Macavity's strategy frustrating, however, I do believe him to be the jailer. If he says he has concrete evidence then I'll go with his votes come day. 

Demarcus

Xenia said:

@Demarcus, I too have found @Macavity's strategy frustrating, however, I do believe him to be the jailer. If he says he has concrete evidence then I'll go with his votes come day. 

I've suspected him to be the Jailer for some time, but these continued tirades and his flopping all over the place seems a little ridiculous. How do we go from you, Xenia, yesterday, to me today? The failure to be consistent, and accurate, leaves a lot to be desired. I'm not suggesting we lynch Macavity, that would be spiteful, but I'm not ruling out that he could be in the Loyalist Conclave. Especially since he thinks that I'm in the Rebel Conclave, which if that is true he'd have the most to gain at that point.

Teani

Points to consider:

- Warden could easily correct Macavity if he was wrong with an anon message.

- Demarcus actually pointed a finger at Piper in his post when voting on Aldric.

- Switching votes after it's an almost done deal could have been a ruse, but not very likely. We still have enough people to pull off the vote.

@Demarcus: Which Conclave would you say it's most likely @Aldric belongs to?