I am voting for Slyphe because he is only one who knew the identify of the Knight-Marshal, and because the Knight-Marshal got hit by the mafia as soon as they were able to. Clearly proving that Slyphe is mafia and told them who to vote for.
It -could- have been a coincidence, but as they hit another power role early on, that's way too many coincidences for my liking. It's much more likely that Damariel was right after all and Slyphe is the grand poobah, or however it's spelled.
Incidentally, Aarbrok's defence of Slyphe indicates that he, too, is mafia.
Slyphe's persistent need to get rid of Damariel does make me highly suspicious, along with Aarbrok as well. However, I'm still gonna stick with my original gut feeling as I had before and go with Ilyon again.
I'd rather vote for aarbrok but at the same time ilyon seems to be confusing the game against slyphe.
The quotes I posted were what I noticed last round that made me suspect the identity of the knight marshall. It's not unreasonable to think that others, like ilyon, would spot that to and use it to their advantage to off another innocent.
Come on now, do I need to take out the crayons? This is basic stuff.
- Slyphe learns who Alee is - Immediately afterwards, Alee gets targeted by mafia, despite not raising any suspicion - Therefore, Slyphe is mafia - That, or the mafia got incredibly lucky. Twice in a row. Yeah, not buying that. - Several people are doing their best to deflect the vote away from Slyphe. Another clear sign.
Anyway, the recent Slyphe-defending posts show that Aarbrok (99% sure) and Aren (80% sure) are the other two mafia members, so if you for some inexplicable reason don't want to hit Slyphe, we can switch to Aarbrok instead, but it's a higher risk.
Or, I guess, the mafia could win. Up to you, really, all you need to do is lynch two more townies.
I know I am dead but this is about Aren's signature... every time I see it I have to stop and watch it for at least half a minute... I don't know why... I just have to.
"We're tired of this! Too many numbers!" shouts one of the three people left rioting. An accusatory finger points towards Slyphe as a rioter shouts, "You! You were in cahoots with the Knight-Marshall, you must be behind all of this! DIE!"
It takes awhile, but the crowd of 2 eventually manages to bludgeon Slyphe to death.
The Grand Poohbah pulls the cowl down from his cloak and steps out of the shadows, clapping slowly. "Congratulations. You've all lost. Now bow down to your new masters." You recognize him as Damonicus!
Two very Shadowy Assassins stand behind your new Vanpoohguard and you immediately recognize them as Aarbrok and Llok!
"NOOOOO! I DIDN'T GET TO LYNCH ANYONE!" cries Aren as he tears a very deceptive mask off his face, revealing himsel to be none other than Haven Locke!
Aren lunges at Ilyon wielding a noose in one last desperate attempt to lynch Some Poor Sap. He is struck down by twin arrows from the Shadowy Assassins, sparing Ilyon from getting out of his future servitude to his new leaders.
The Instigators win!
The Enorians lose!
Haven Locke also loses!
Thanks everyone for playing, I'm calling it a game at this point since I doubt The Instigators are going to assassinate one of their own at night. It was entertaining to see how the posts and lynching goes knowing everyone's identities! I apologize for any rules clarities that contributed to the bumps in the game. A lucky Round 1 kill on the Vanguard really set The Instigators up for success. I can't believe how badly I was cheering for the trains started on Llok and then Aarbrok to succeed to give the Enorians a fighting chance! Oh well. I hope everyone learned something and most important had fun. It was a fairly quick game compared to others, which I think helped! Hopefully there won't be such a tremendous pause inbetween this and our next game!
I just got too annoyed to bother with trying to argue any points, but from the start I had been saying to lynch Aarbrok because I could tell he was guilty.
That game was aggravating. Watching Moirean's attempt to create an alliance fail so quickly was aggravating, watching you all vote for me was aggravating, and then watching you all vote for Slyphe - when I knew that the investigator's death was proof that Slyphe was innocent after all - was aggravating. In fact, the suspicion I was expressing toward Slyphe? It was done on the assumption that he and the investigator would both survive into the next round, and the scum would spare him because I was unwilling to consider him 100% confirmed... such that we could keep getting reliable investigation reports.
Well the decision for Slyphe was (We have two people Toz and Slyphe who seem to be making logical arguments, and Alee seems to be ally with Slyphe, so lets off him in case he knows anything.)
In fact, the suspicion I was expressing toward Slyphe? It was done on the assumption that he and the investigator would both survive into the next round, and the scum would spare him because I was unwilling to consider him 100% confirmed...
Yeah, it's interesting how things turn out sometimes. This strategy backfired largely because of our inexperience with such tactics. Hopefully we'll know better next time!
Quite an informative and interesting game, that's for sure. Too bad it was so short.
Comments
It -could- have been a coincidence, but as they hit another power role early on, that's way too many coincidences for my liking. It's much more likely that Damariel was right after all and Slyphe is the grand poobah, or however it's spelled.
Incidentally, Aarbrok's defence of Slyphe indicates that he, too, is mafia.
Vote: Ilyon
I'd rather vote for aarbrok but at the same time ilyon seems to be confusing the game against slyphe.
The quotes I posted were what I noticed last round that made me suspect the identity of the knight marshall. It's not unreasonable to think that others, like ilyon, would spot that to and use it to their advantage to off another innocent.
- Slyphe learns who Alee is
- Immediately afterwards, Alee gets targeted by mafia, despite not raising any suspicion
- Therefore, Slyphe is mafia
- That, or the mafia got incredibly lucky. Twice in a row. Yeah, not buying that.
- Several people are doing their best to deflect the vote away from Slyphe. Another clear sign.
Anyway, the recent Slyphe-defending posts show that Aarbrok (99% sure) and Aren (80% sure) are the other two mafia members, so if you for some inexplicable reason don't want to hit Slyphe, we can switch to Aarbrok instead, but it's a higher risk.
Or, I guess, the mafia could win. Up to you, really, all you need to do is lynch two more townies.
UNVOTE: Ilyon
VOTE: Slyphe
Unvote: Ilyon
Vote: Slyphe
Could Ilyon be haven?
Vote: Slyphe
It takes awhile, but the crowd of 2 eventually manages to bludgeon Slyphe to death.
Slyphe: Ilyon, Aarbrok, Aren, Toz, Damonicus (5)
Aarbrok: Xenia (1)
Slyphe has been lynched!
He was a Citizen!
The Grand Poohbah pulls the cowl down from his cloak and steps out of the shadows, clapping slowly. "Congratulations. You've all lost. Now bow down to your new masters." You recognize him as Damonicus!
Two very Shadowy Assassins stand behind your new Vanpoohguard and you immediately recognize them as Aarbrok and Llok!
"NOOOOO! I DIDN'T GET TO LYNCH ANYONE!" cries Aren as he tears a very deceptive mask off his face, revealing himsel to be none other than Haven Locke!
Aren lunges at Ilyon wielding a noose in one last desperate attempt to lynch Some Poor Sap. He is struck down by twin arrows from the Shadowy Assassins, sparing Ilyon from getting out of his future servitude to his new leaders.
The Instigators win!
The Enorians lose!
Haven Locke also loses!
Thanks everyone for playing, I'm calling it a game at this point since I doubt The Instigators are going to assassinate one of their own at night. It was entertaining to see how the posts and lynching goes knowing everyone's identities! I apologize for any rules clarities that contributed to the bumps in the game. A lucky Round 1 kill on the Vanguard really set The Instigators up for success. I can't believe how badly I was cheering for the trains started on Llok and then Aarbrok to succeed to give the Enorians a fighting chance! Oh well. I hope everyone learned something and most important had fun. It was a fairly quick game compared to others, which I think helped! Hopefully there won't be such a tremendous pause inbetween this and our next game!
Thanks for hosting the game, it's been fun!
Ahh, well.
Quite an informative and interesting game, that's for sure. Too bad it was so short.