Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
- 3.7K All Categories
- 3K The Midnight Age
- 757 Announce posts
- 125 Newbies
- 6 Class Guides
- 804 Harpy's Head Tavern
- 57 Echo Canyon
- 310 Self-Affirmations
- 163 Town Crier
- 135 The Exchange
- 167 Sparring Grounds
- Combat Guides
- 30 Combat Logs
- 188 Idea Box
- 9 Classleads
- 578 Roleplay Logs
- 107 Aetolia Development
- 5 The Void
- 744 Miscellaneous
- 9 Announcements
- 417 OOC Chat
- 217 Tech Talk
- 47 Scripts
Looking for more active discussion? Join our Discord at https://discord.gg/x2s7fY6
Comments
The bolded part is what makes me pause. To me it reads as if you await some kind of confirmation on whether everyone got a PM or not, and until you do, you're going to assume everyone got one.
Based on my knowledge, I consider it confirmed that not everyone got a PM, thus making me believe that since you require confirmation, you actually did get a PM, making you a power role.
I thought maybe I should toss that out there for others to read it again and say if my English really is that bad or not.
The reason I didn't want to change my vote is because I would've gone to a no lynch last round, and from what I've read, that would've made me look more guilty? So I'm sort of in a pickle now.
Vote: Llok
I agree with what Moirean had to say about his posts. He might even be mafia and we could hit two with one stone!
Serrice is reluctant to trust the both of us, however, I think it's in the town's best interest if the dirty cop were to contact me at this time.
I have been debating on whether Aryanne's death was the result of the dirty cop and perhaps the mafia attempted to snipe Serrice, or if the cop has not used up any bullets yet.
Politics
Idk, I feel like it's paramount that if Xenia is lying and there is a real Jailer out there, that they should claim right now.
Vote: Jami
This is more of a hunch than anything, but she made a total of two posts, first of which was "I play for the first time", and second one was "Demarcus sounds like scum", which sounds like a mafia trying to blend in.
Also still suspicious of Piper, as we had a train on Piper in the first round and it got random-diverted towards Demarcus.
I changed my vote to Xenia because her actions came off as really suspicious and it seemed like we'd have a way of verifying one scum on day one (both Serrice and Xenia had claimed the fencer role so one was obviously lying and why the hell would a townie do that?). I changed my vote from Xenia because everyone else had already jumped another train and we were obviously not going to lynch her on day one, at which point my vote on her was not doing anything at all. If I was indeed mafia, I would have kept my vote on her to avoid suspicion and let whoever else felt like day one was dragging on for too long to seal Demarcus's fate (a train that did not really make any sense to me at all in the first place).
People kept going back and forth without really comitting to anything and it was confuzzling the hell out of me because there was no logic to what was going on.
Your gambit from the last game was make or break, a hero if you won or a villain if you lost. And I would have applauded you had you won, but you didn't and I needed a way to break away from my mafia companions so I targeted Aarbrok. Exposed what gave the detective away and villainised you to get people on my side.
This game my comment wasn't really targeted at you at all but the entire vote train to one who hasn't had a great deal of time came out of nowhere. It was random diversion off someone with a reasonable cause to lynch.
I have a few questions because I dont have an amazing amount of times.
Is Xenia the jailor?
Slyphe, please don't be so harsh with your comments, last game we targeted you as the one to do our job for us and you did it better than any of us could. Thanks.
The diversion of the train away from Xenia (which I read as primarily lead by Moirean) struck me as dodgy, seeing as Demarcus had done nothing that seemed questionable, bar try to talk about what was going on. The telling point is that the train on Xenia wouldn't stick while the train on an innocent went full speed ahead.
We have a number of quiet people. Typical scum play would be to hide among the various groups that form.
There's the quiet people which Demarcus did last game.
The semi posters who add reasonable logic to the game. (I did this last game, FU if you think I didnt :P )
The loud posters who draw a lot of attention, aka Aarbrok.
I don't see any reason for Xenia to not have died last night if she's the jailor. Mafia trying to bait us in to wasting a day round on her? Possibly.
@ Parker - Moirean said you jumped onto a train with little visibility which is why she voted for you. I voted you for the irony of the reason presented.
I want to agree with Ilyon, however, sounds like a good call.
Vote: Jami
Why I claimed fencer:
1. Fencer can be killed by the mafia's sniper rifle at night without taking out any of the mafioso.
2. At the time, before Serrice CC'd me, I was the only person who had inadvertently claimed a power role.
3. I assumed that since I was not mafia, that the mafia would likely look to off me in the night.
4. If I said I was the fencer then the mafia would waste their sniper shot on me, and the real fencer would be safe from that.
5. I would get a role call from the town, tell those people that I was actually the jailer.
6. I figured that the fencer would not speak up because they know that if anyone attacks them they would kill them, but not if they were shot by a sniper rifle; a fake fencer would mean a wasted sniper shot.
Why I jailed fencer:
1. I figure mafia is wavering between me and Serrice. Since Llok, you and a number of others are already suspicious of me, my guess is they may try and off Serrice.
2. They can do so safely with the sniper rifle, but not if she is locked in my jail cell.
3. Anyone in a jail cell is immune to all attacks, however I am always a sitting duck.
4. On the chance that they attacked Serrice, whom I believe to be the true fencer (perhaps incorrectly), there would still be 2 town power roles alive.
Am I speaking to the real Investigator?
1. A mafioso will not gain any new information about who is who by reaching out to me, this also goes for including Serrice in on the conversation.
2. The best a fake investigator can do is guide us in the wrong direction on who to lynch, however they seem to be as unsure as I, in that they spent their evening investigating me.
3. I am likely going to be killed off tonight by the mafia, if it is the real investigator, then they need a voice to speak through, Serrice will have to be that voice.
4. If the investigator dies tonight then it's possible that Serrice or I are not who we say we are. I felt it important to make the information that someone claiming to be the investigator had reached out to me to the town.
My actions from this point forward:
1. I have made a number of mistakes in that first day, I don't see myself as the best 'leader' to the town. Since I am pretty much out there with an X on my head, to both sides, the best I can do is offer information, my own logic, and hope that the town prevails.
2. There are 16 people alive. If I assume that everyone who has claimed a role to me is telling the truth, this gives gives me 13 people who are possibly guilty. 2/13 (15%) is the dirty cop and the innocent, 1/13 (8%) is the lover, 4/13 (31%) are the mafia.
3. The dirty cop will investigate as guilty, this may throw the investigator off accidentally. If we can save some time and confusion on this with a PM from the dirty cop to me, this will likely be good for the town.
We still have quite a few people who have not said anything for this day. I want to hear them speak up before I can try to determine who is on my side or not, and that I can trust.
Xenia's openess makes it appear I can, but I am leery.
Vote: Xenia
From how I'm reading it, there's no facilitated note passing. So, basically, we contact each other, and can claim a role. There's no sort of verification in there, and anyone can PM anyone else saying they are whatever role they want.