Looking for more active discussion? Join our Discord at https://discord.gg/x2s7fY6
Ilyon
Comments
-
I'd be very reluctant on making any decisions based on whether either conclave used their night kill or not -- unless they are informed of every jailing, they likely don't even know that they have the night kill. in Mafia: The Rellyw Rebellion - Game Thread Comment by Ilyon August 2013
-
Well. While you two are battling it out, I think I'll stick with my vote from round 2.
VOTE: Meskhenet
-
@Omei On the previous day's voting lists, the numbers do not match up - dask has 12 votes and 13 people listed, while mesk has 3 votes and 2 people - is that just a mis…
-
On the voting lists, the numbers do not match up - dask has 12 votes and 13 people listed, while mesk has 3 votes and 2 people. Is that meant to be like that?
-
He's already at 13 (yours included), with 12 needed.
-
Heh, I think most people are, as you say, freaking lost. Things will hopefully improve as the number of roles and factions starts declining later on.
-
Well, the syssin should be sending the info in anonymous messages, that's why they are there for - the chance of fake messages is fairly minimal there as the warden can confirm if the described person was actually targeted.
-
Thing is, we really don't have much information to build upon. There are three different groups that do not know who each other is, which means that it is entirely possible for a member of one to initiate or follow a lynch against a member of anothe…
-
Huh, why is half the post black and half white
-
Mkay, so.
VOTE: Meskhenet
Inactive people are inactive, people whose only relevant post is a train hop are suspicious. Meskhenet is both.
-
If you have any important role, posting that here may not have been the best idea :P
-
Okay, as much as I'm not looking forward to yet another round of Llok-distractions, this does make sense.
UNVOTE: Llok
VOTE: Desian
-
I think it is likely that you are indeed innocent, but it feels risky to rely on that too much, as misdirection is not unheard of.
I also don't really want to deal with Llok's convoluted logic attempts, so unless a better candidate exists… -
Quiet is not inherently guilty, but it does strongly imply being guilty.
-
Interesting. This would prove that Moirean is not an indorani ... I wonder if the fact that no conclave attacked anyone would also prove that she's not in either conclave?
Uh, you do realize that the anonymous messages are also posted in the thread for everyone to see, right? The Warden's only advantage, based on what was said, is that he/she sees which power role (but not which player) sent what.
Sigh, very well. It seems that despite the Indorani being the only faction whom a nolynch really helps, the opinion that the alternative is too risky prevails, and there is basically zero chance of agreeing on any single person. Letting Omei do the …Well what do you know, this "call people out to get them to participate" thing is actually working. Let's see ...
UNVOTE: Haern
VOTE: Aldric
Okay, having thought about this a bit, I'm becoming increasingly convinced that we do not want to do a nolynch. Yes, things can get nasty if we give one of the conclaves a majority, but it is crucial to remember that this is going to happen regardle…The jailer cannot protect himself.
Mm, I am not so sure if most agree on nolynch being a bad idea. I'm kind of on the fence myself, as while we gain little information from a nolynch, it is also true that the groups who can gain the most are the conclaves, not the rellyw.
@Macavity - the chance is 36%, not 56.25% (9/25, not 9/16), and as I note above, hitting a conclave member could backfire while the indorani are in play.
Hrrm. I'm not so sure on the vigilante reveal. It would work initially, but if the rebel conclave loses a member, the loyalist conclave could easily remove the vigilante.
The big question, then. To lynch or to nolynch? The worst thing tha…The indorani still get to kill someone, even if the conclaves don't, making nolynch sound like a bad idea.
On a more positive note, I am listed twice!
Mm, this does look rather complex, hopefully it won't get confusing! Random questions:
- Dhasan of Nature: can his target still post during day rounds?
- Dhasan of Art: will the active role user be told about the illusion (I'm assuming not…