Greetings, fellow mortals! I am here to make a case for why Aetolia needs katanas. BIG OL FAT NOTE, HOWEVER: I am actually wholly in-favor of having an in-universe name for them. I actually think the argument for avoiding the
word itself is pretty solid given the game's setting in general. This is solidly about why we need an entirely separate item type.
My argument for Katanas-In-Aetolia (KIA if you will) is simple: we don't have a good way to describe this type of weapon. Yes, we have curved swords already (scimitars and sabres), and we already have longswords, but these conditions are limited. Specifically, the appearance, the
most-seen, and arguably the
most important line for any crafted item, has a 50 character limit, and devoting this to lines that really sell the aesthetic of the crafted item is going to reduce crafting creativity. Examples:
- a single-edged, curved longsword (64% of the appearance character allocation)
- a thinly-forged scimitar (48% of the appearance character allocation)
- a sabre that's kinda not a sabre but is straightish but still curved (136% of the appearance character allocation!)
vs:
- a kituna (a mere 16% of the appearance allocation!)
I'm actually total butt at naming things (please do not name it a kituna) but that's the crux of my argument. A katana is a distinct weapon from a sabre, and while it
is arguably comparable to a longsword, it really could serve as either its own item type, or as a reference for longswords, simply because it gives people a lot more freedom for customization and crafting.
That's my main argument, and honestly I think that alone is pretty compelling, but I'm sure others have better ones, or good ways to tell me why I'm wrong and stupid and a weeb, even though I've only watched, like, three animes.
EDIT: Made this thread more broad to be about items you'd like to see in Aetolia that are currently a huge pain in the rear to design. I think I made the solid case on
why having specific names is good, so now it's time: come up with your own weapons and other items that have no Aetolian counterpart! Also please come up with a better name that kituna.